From the archive
When Do Eastern Indian Ocean Pygmy Blue Whales Sing?
Prefer Family & Pets on GoogleSee more of our stories in your results
Do pygmy blue whales in the eastern Indian Ocean sing more at night? A study in Royal Society Open Science reports that, under the conditions it examined, song production at the population level was greater at night. The night-song finding came from underwater acoustic recordings. In a separate analysis, the researchers used 130.1 days of tag data to model how feeding dives might limit the time available to sing. A neighbouring question stays open: does any single whale sing more at night? An earlier study of one tagged eastern Indian Ocean whale found that it spent a larger share of daytime than nighttime singing. One result describes a population and the other describes an individual. Either can hold without telling us why the results differ.
A microphone tells you when a sound reaches its recording station. Dive telemetry provides another kind of record, about the movements of the whale carrying a tag. The larger study used both kinds of data. Together they gave researchers a way to ask whether the timing of feeding dives might help explain the timing of songs.
What an underwater microphone measures
A hydrophone is an underwater microphone. It detects small changes in water pressure and converts them into a signal. That record can be examined later for the sound researchers are interested in. In the 2026 Royal Society Open Science study, Davenport and colleagues used passive acoustic recordings to compare song heard by day and by night. Their question starts with the sound arriving at the recorder, in the places where they had records to examine.
That strength carries a built-in limit. A recording of song shows that song was present. It does not show which whale made it, how many whales were singing, or what any of them were doing at the time. In the Royal Society Open Science study, the acoustic record is what supports a statement about the population, because it captures the soundscape rather than following one animal.
Here is a hypothetical, with invented numbers, to show the limit. Suppose a recorder detects song in 6 of 10 night hours and 3 of 10 daytime hours. That is 60 percent of night hours against 30 percent of daytime hours, so song is twice as common at night in that made-up record. The recording alone cannot say whether one whale sang for six hours or six whales each sang for one.
What dive tags measure
A dive tag is a small device attached to an animal that logs how it moves through the water. In the pygmy blue whale work, that record describes diving behaviour. An earlier tag study, held in the University of Western Australia's research repository, tracked pygmy blue whale diving and validated feeding activity along the migration route. That validation matters because feeding is not directly visible in a dive record. Researchers need evidence that a particular kind of dive really corresponds to feeding before they can treat it as feeding.
The 2026 study combined 130.1 days of diving data from 12 eastern Indian Ocean pygmy blue whales, including the whale Davenport and colleagues followed for 7.6 days in their 2022 single-whale study. The tag configurations varied. The depth and movement records helped the scientists classify dives and estimate which parts of a whale’s day might leave time to sing. The researchers used acoustic records in a separate part of the analysis to look at when song occurred.
How the two kinds of data were related
The Royal Society Open Science study relied on a model. A model here is a set of explicit assumptions about how something might work, written so that it can be compared with measurements. The idea under test was that feeding dives might constrain singing: time a whale spends in feeding dives is time it may not have for song. The model treated feeding dives as a possible constraint on the time available to sing. The acoustic data describe when song was heard.
Putting the two side by side lets researchers ask whether the timing of song is the kind of pattern a feeding schedule could produce. The reported result is that song production was greater at night under the studied conditions. Whether feeding dives are the reason is a separate and harder claim, because a model that fits the data shows consistency, not proof.
Why a population and one whale can differ
In the 2022 single-whale study, Davenport and colleagues followed one eastern Indian Ocean pygmy blue whale for 7.6 days. That whale spent a larger share of daytime than nighttime singing, and it sang most during twilight. One animal over 7.6 days gives researchers one time budget. A recording station tracks the song reaching its microphone over time.
A hypothetical shows how both can be true. Imagine 10 singers in a room, where 9 sing only in the evening and 1 sings only at midday. A listener at the door hears mostly evening song, 9 singers out of 10. A person who follows the midday singer records only midday song. Neither is mistaken. They measured different things. The comparison stops working quickly, because whales are not a choir with fixed schedules, and the number of animals behind the population record is not something these numbers settle.
The 130.1 days of tag data came from 12 whales with unequal tracking periods and different tag configurations. That number describes the dive records. The count of whales in those records cannot tell us how many individuals were singing in any particular hour recorded by an underwater microphone.
Is the feeding explanation too tidy?
It is a satisfying story: feeding takes time, singing needs time, and the schedule explains the song. Satisfying stories earn trust faster than they should, which is why rival explanations matter. Other things could produce the same hourly pattern, such as differences in where whales were or in what else they were doing, and the finding applies to the conditions the study examined.
There is a practical objection to all this care. A clean sentence such as whales sing at night is easier to remember than a population-level result under studied conditions. The cost of the clean sentence is visible in the single tagged whale, which spent a larger share of daytime than nighttime singing. The two studies measured different things. The population pattern does not tell us how that whale divided its time. The cleaner story gains momentum and loses the part that makes the finding interesting.
How to look again
The next time you see a headline about when an animal feeds, calls or sleeps, ask what the researchers actually counted. They could be following one animal closely, looking at the movements of several, or listening across an area. The answer tells you whether to picture one animal’s day or an activity that seems more common at a certain hour across the study area.
Then check the units. The time one whale spent singing belongs to its own time budget. Song detected at a recording station belongs to that place and period. In both cases the observation is worth having. The choice of measurement tells you how far to take it before you need another source.



